AbsolutePunk.net

AbsolutePunk.net (http://www.absolutepunk.net/forum.php)
-  Sports (http://www.absolutepunk.net/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
  -  Rank the 32 NFL Starting QBs (http://www.absolutepunk.net/showthread.php?t=2472262)

startBBtoday 10/10/11 06:37 PM

Rank the 32 NFL Starting QBs
 
  1. Tom Brady
  2. Aaron Rodgers
  3. Drew Brees
  4. Philip Rivers
  5. Ben Roethlisberger
  6. Matt Schaub
  7. Tony Romo
  8. Matthew Stafford
  9. Matt Ryan
  10. Michael Vick
  11. Joe Flacco
  12. Ryan Fitzpatrick
  13. Josh Freeman
  14. Eli Manning
  15. Jay Cutler
  16. Matt Hasselbeck
  17. Sam Bradford
  18. Cam Newton
  19. Mark Sanchez
  20. Matt Cassel
  21. Jason Campbell
  22. Colt McCoy
  23. Alex Smith
  24. Kevin Kolb
  25. Rex Grossman
  26. Andy Dalton
  27. Tarvaris Jackson
  28. Tim Tebow
  29. Blaine Gabbert
  30. Curtis Painter
  31. Donovan McNabb
  32. Matt Moore
here's mine. rank em. current ranks, not just this season, not based off entire scope of career.

youenvydoug 10/10/11 07:15 PM

30. Painter 31. Sanchez 32. Moore

/I'm on my phone and don't feel like making my full list.

spiffa0 10/10/11 07:15 PM

Tebow isn't even a definite starter yet. If he was he'd be 32 for me

startBBtoday 10/10/11 07:18 PM

if orton is still the starter i'd put him right beneath jason campbell.

mfields10 10/10/11 08:02 PM

Rodgers>Brady

But I understand the home team favoritism.

Romo is too high, Newton is too low.
McNabb is probably also too low.

Other than that, your list is pretty solid.

startBBtoday 10/10/11 08:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mfields10 (Post 96226392)
Rodgers>Brady

But I understand the home team favoritism.

Romo is too high, Newton is too low.
McNabb is probably also too low.

Other than that, your list is pretty solid.


who would you put above romo?

kyle is hk 10/10/11 08:04 PM

edit- see updated

badger52683 10/10/11 08:05 PM

No Peyton Manning?

cococrisp20 10/10/11 08:06 PM

  1. Aaron Rodgers
  2. Drew Brees
  3. Tom Brady
  4. Philip Rivers
  5. Matthew Stafford
  6. Mike Vick
  7. Matt Schaub
  8. Joe Flacco
  9. Ryan Fitzpatrick
  10. Cam Newton
  11. Matt Hasselbeck
  12. Eli Manning
  13. Josh Freeman
  14. Matt Ryan
  15. Ben Roethlesberger
  16. Sam Bradford
  17. Tavaris Jackson
  18. Rex Grossman
  19. Matt Cassel
  20. Jason Campbell
  21. Colt McCoy
  22. Kyle Orton
  23. Kevin Kolb
  24. Mark Sanchez
  25. Andy Dalton
  26. Jay Cutler
  27. Alex Smith
  28. Blaine Gabbert
  29. Curtis Painter
  30. Donovan McNabb
  31. Matt Moore
I forgot someone but I can't figure out who

spiffa0 10/10/11 08:08 PM

lol Ben at 15.

startBBtoday 10/10/11 08:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by badger52683 (Post 96226592)
No Peyton Manning?


not currently starting.

xbrokendownx 10/10/11 08:08 PM

matt moore!

kyle is hk 10/10/11 08:09 PM

smh at people putting Rodgers over Brady.

kyle is hk 10/10/11 08:16 PM

Thread inspired me to possibly be the first person ever in the history of AP to rock an Alex Smith avatar.

mfields10 10/10/11 08:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by startBBtoday (Post 96226492)
who would you put above romo?


Not really sure. See, I'm a Redskins so I too am biased.
I just feel like you cannot put someone that has choked away a lead twice (so far in his four games) at number 8.
It's not that he is a bad quarterback, he just lacks that clutch factor that should be present in a top ten quarterback.

The same goes for Vick (whom I actually despise more), but at least he can run...