[woohoo!]

Which TBS lineup is everyone's favorite?
Since their first album it's always been Adam Lazarra [Lead Vocals], Mark O'Connell [Drums], and Eddie Reyes [Guitar], but they've had a few variations over the years. I've seen polls for their best album, but what about best lineup?

John Nolan (Guitar & Vocals)/Shaun Cooper (Bass) [Tell All Your Friends/Self Titled],
Fred Mascherino (Guitar & Vocals)/Matt Rubano (Bass) [Where You Want to Be/Louder Now], or
Matt Fazzi (Guitar & Vocals)/Matt Rubano (Bass) [New Again/Live from Orensanz]

[DanPiazza]

So yeah, Nolan created the first record I truly fell in love with...but Fred helped craft an album that landed right as I entered high school. I will never forget each and every track; from This Photograph Is Proof to Slowdance On the Inside. Where You Want to Be brings back so many memories...

[TheZeroKid]

Every poll that pits Nolan and Mascherino against each other gets the same answer from me: Nolan's a better songwriter, Mascherino's voice is a better fit with Lazzara's.

Come on, guys, Fazzi (and by extension, New Again) was not THAT bad.

[surette]

gotta go with John.

[ArtOfJordan]

Originally Posted by TheZeroKid

Every poll that pits Nolan and Mascherino against each other gets the same answer from me: Nolan's a better songwriter, Mascherino's voice is a better fit with Lazzara's.

^These are my thoughts as well.

[woohoo!]

Originally Posted by TheZeroKid

Every poll that pits Nolan and Mascherino against each other gets the same answer from me: Nolan's a better songwriter, Mascherino's voice is a better fit with Lazzara's.

Come on, guys, Fazzi (and by extension, New Again) was not THAT bad.

yeah i definitely have to agree that fred had the best fit vocally with adam, but i think that fred is a way better guitar songwriter than john. i didn't think anything off the newest album beat anything fred wrote, and "cute without the e" was written by their drummer mark. and yeah i think that new again was way better than the new one. if there were more backup vocals it could have been much better

[moreneon]

This is impossible for me. John is the cutest though, so him.

[Feenucks]

I'm going to say Fred and Matt, but ONLY because Where You Want To Be is their best album. Otherwise, it's John and Shaun.

[daftpunker45]

TAYF is great and Self-Titled is good, but Fred and Matt put out 2 great records.

[KenneyBN]

The one with Jesse Lacey in it.

[phil19]

im amazed nolan and cooper dont have 100% of the vote

[aradiantsunrise]

I like Nolan and Cooper more as musicians, but WYWTB is my favorite album by TBS.

[BozzBlonde]

Fred 5eva

[tortags]

Originally Posted by aradiantsunrise

I like Nolan and Cooper more as musicians, but WYWTB is my favorite album by TBS.

This. ^