[Explode]

The last thread for this was years ago, so I believe it's due.

[surette]

haven't listened to Southern Air yet, so went with When You're Through Thinking.

[DanPiazza]

Southern Air is making a strong case for my favorite, but Ocean Avenue has too much nostalgic value for me.

[Brandon Allin]

I like most of this band's discography a lot, always consistent, but nothing will ever top Ocean Avenue for me.

[RyanGarner]

Ocean Avenue if only for the ridiculous nostalgia it gives me.

[Garcia1]

It is amazing!

[daftpunker45]

WYTTSY is amazing as is Southern Air, but Paper Walls is perfect and Ocean Avenue is overrated, but still good.

[SLoT]

Paper Walls > Ocean Avenue > Southern Air > Lights and Sounds > When You're Through... > doesn't matter at this point, I don't listen to their old shit anymore.

[phil19]

LOVE one for the kids

[Cody Nelson]

Paper Walls > WYTTSY > Lights and Sounds > Ocean Avenue > One for the Kids

Southern Air will probably be my favorite after awhile, but I don't know where it fits yet.

[MyFriendsOver]

Ocean Avenue is perfect. It goes beyond nostalgia for me; there is so much emotion and energy on that album, and every single song has a memorable melody. 10/10

I have very high hopes for Southern Air. I have a feeling that will become my second favorite by them!

[tyler2tall147]

Wow, no love to Lights and Sounds. I always figuired that was like their Cult classic

[jordalsh]

Paper Walls>When You're Through Thinking, Say Yes>Ocean Avenue>Lights and Sounds>One For The Kids

Southern Air is really good. It's too early to give a definite ranking, but I can see it being number two or possibly one with time. Paper Walls has just always meant a lot to me so it's hard to top.

[Advrt]

Midget Tossing all the way.

[herbienay]

Originally Posted by tyler2tall147

Wow, no love to Lights and Sounds. I always figuired that was like their Cult classic

Paper Walls is the cult classic.