[Domenic182]

This poll hasn't been done for a while so I figured I'd ask. I'm lumping all the Alchemy Indexes together. Hope that's cool with folks.

[RyanGarner]

Vheissu>The Artist in the Ambulance=The Illusion of Safety>The Alchemy Index>Major/Minor>Beggars

but they're all so close.

[KenneyBN]

This changes kind of frequently for me...

[deanster321]

Major/Minor

[herbienay]

Artist

[flks511]

Everyone knows Beggars is the best.

[entrailable]

Originally Posted by KenneyBN

This changes kind of frequently for me...

Same here, but gun to my head, I have to go with Beggars.

[lonelysuperstar]

Vheissu>The Alchemy Index>Major/Minor>Artist>Beggars>Illusion of Safety>IC

[majinsharingan]

The Alchemy Index>Beggars>Vheissu>Major/Minor=Artist>Illusion of Safety>IC

[suicidesaints]

This is a VERY hard poll. To me comparing Thrice albums is like comparing apples to oranges. Each one is so unique, that the only common thread really is that the same group of musicians created each one.

I think the later stuff is "more mature" but I enjoy some of the older stuff more.

Artist is a long time favorite, but I think I'll choose Major/Minor


edit:
Also really surprised by how well Vheissu is doing in this poll. I like everything Thrice has ever done, but Vheissu is my least favorite record from them.

[defy_stars]

Artist

[speakhandsforme]

There is no excuse for this not being a multiple choice poll.

[notoaststereo]

Beggars
Vhiessu
Major Minor
The Alchemy Index: Earth and Air
The Illusion of Safety
The Artist in the Ambulance
The Alchemy Index: Fire and Water
Identity Crisis

[Neo Cassady]

Artist and Vheissu are basically tied.