[Every Time I Ty]

All awesome CDs in my opinion but let's stack em up best to worst. GO

1. II
2. Billy Talent
3. Dead Silence
4. III

[honkytonk]

I feel like that's pretty much the general consensus

[Neo Cassady]

My ex never gave me back my copy of Billy Talent's II, so I'll substitute Boyz II Men's II instead.

1. II
2. Everything else.

[BozzBlonde]

Originally Posted by honkytonk

I feel like that's pretty much the general consensus

Pretty much.

[NickIsI]

Originally Posted by honkytonk

I feel like that's pretty much the general consensus

I disagree.

1. Billy Talent
2. II
3. Dead Silence
4. III

[leftapart]

1. Billy Talent
And I lost interest after that.

[honkytonk]

Originally Posted by NickIsI

I disagree.

1. Billy Talent
2. II
3. Dead Silence
4. III

Yeah I could go either way really, Billy Talent and II are pretty equal quality in my eyes. The rest is generally agreed upon though I'd say.

[Deborah Remus]

Originally Posted by NickIsI

I disagree.

1. Billy Talent
2. II
3. Dead Silence
4. III

Yep. The first record will probably always be my favourite.

[majinsharingan]

1. II
2. Billy Talent
3. III
4. Dead Silence.

I thought Dead Silence was very weak lyrically. Two times through and I just cannot get into it, which makes me sad because I love their other albums.

[NateFoundGlory]

Yeah,

1. II
2. Billy Talent
3. Dead Silence
4. III

I will comment on how solid Dead Silence is, though. Much better than I predicted.

[NickIsI]

Originally Posted by Deborah Remus

Yep. The first record will probably always be my favourite.

Mine too!

[CalRahhh]

II was the only one that grabbed me at all. So II > the rest.

[suicidalmoose]

Originally Posted by Every Time I Ty

All awesome CDs in my opinion but let's stack em up best to worst. GO

1. II
2. Billy Talent
3. Dead Silence
4. III

This. I like them all, though.

[Hail Lelouch]

people saying 2 is better than their debut?

no no no

[wall e]

1. Billy Talent
2. II

that's all I've heard.