Album Review
Kate Voegele - A Fine Mess Album Cover

Kate Voegele - A Fine Mess

Reviewed by
Kate Voegele - A Fine Mess
Record Label: Myspace/Interscope
Release Date: May 19, 2009
This review was written by an AP.net staff member.
Along with Sherwood and Hollywood Undead, Kate Voegele has the distinct honor of being one of the initial artists on California's MySpace Records, a joint venture with Interscope that at present has fourteen artists. Voegele's debut Don't Look Away sold 225,000 units and did quite well on West Coast radio. The 23-year-old Ohio native's sophomore album A Fine Mess, is nine analogus bubblegum pop clunkers that never deviate away from their comfort zone and never get daring until the final stretch.

The summery and freewheeling disc was produced by Mike Elizondo, whose most notable contributions to date are Dr. Dre, 50 Cent and Eminem, though he's also worked with Switchfoot, Maroon 5, Alanis Morisette, Pink and Nelly Furtado, to name but a few. The latter three of Morissette, Pink and Furtado say the most about what Elizondo brings to the table on A Fine Mess. Clearly the man knows how to work with female vocals and push them to the forefront, while also managing a solid hook, both of which he does quite well on this album.

There are no real missteps on A Fine Mess but then again it's only nine tracks. The biggest problem is there's nothing entirely memorable or substantial. The album's first three songs are all radio-ready singles, with "99 Times," standing out as the most likely to leave a dent on the Billboard charts. Her attempts at mid-tempo ("Angel") and the playful ("Playing With My Heart") are both strong, with "Playing With My Heart," a veritable LeAnn Rimes knock-off being most notable. Around this point, the disc shows a few more dimensions. Aided by piano, "Sweet Silver Lining," is a sweetly satisfying stab at heartbreak that's panged and somber, and proves that even amidst the muck, there's still something that stands out about her.

"Manhattan From the Sky," is a literary approach at the demise of a relationship, and while it's commendable for it's intentions, it's quite awkward in its simile. Likening a boy to an aerial view of New York City is original and tangible but not exactly proper. Saying that said male is like the city and not is the city is the key difference. But then again, Alanis Morisette got away with muddying syntax on "Ironic" and made a single out of it, so why the heck wouldn't Voegele be able to do that here?

A Fine Mess is not a total wash. There's plenty of accessible and charismatic choruses here that will find favor among many Hannah Montana and pop-country fans, but is that exactly how an artist wants to be defined? Voegele actually has a compelling press kit, including appearances at Farm Aid, past winner of the New York City Songwriters Circle and high praise at the USA Songwriting Competition. But such accolades can only take one so far. The real test will be to see what Voegele does next time out. One can only hope she taps into the singer/songwriter vibe of "Talkin' Smooth," and the piano confessional of "Lift Me Up," and puts together something compelling, creative and crafty, because as it stands now, even with her blossoming acting career, she's a dime a dozen.

Track Listing 1. Inside Out.
2. 99 Times
3. Who You Are Without Me
4. Angel
5. Sweet Silver Lining
6. Playing With my Heart
7. Manhattan From the Sky
8. Talkin' Smooth
9. Lift Me Up

Recommended If You LikeVanessa Carlton, Michelle Branch, Fefe Dobson, Missy Higgins and One Tree Hill

Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 20
02:10 PM on 06/04/09
Blake Solomon
every outcome's such a comedown
User Info.
Blake Solomon's Avatar
i'm facebook friends with her! She's hot! Not sure about her music, though!

02:14 PM on 06/04/09
Gregory Robson
Under Rug Swept
User Info.
Gregory Robson's Avatar
i'm facebook friends with her! She's hot! Not sure about her music, though!

She is quite pretty, yes. She's quite blah as a musician though.
02:19 PM on 06/04/09
katy song
User Info.
doppelganger's Avatar
72 is higher than i thought it would be. did the album cover sway you?
03:55 PM on 06/04/09
User Info.
WhoSaidThat?'s Avatar
If this album is any better than her acting, I'll happily give it a chance.
08:23 AM on 06/05/09
User Info.
deezee's Avatar
She's hot, I'm proud she's from Ohio lol
08:25 AM on 06/05/09
Registered User
User Info.
trebmal's Avatar
i'm facebook friends with her! She's hot! Not sure about her music, though!

I think she befriended everyone that has a myspace profile.
08:56 AM on 06/05/09
Not everything, not yet
User Info.
CarouselBoy's Avatar
my sister and girlfriend love her. And my girlfriend talks about how hot she is. Not sure how I should feel about that. Strange it has only 9 tracks.
10:50 AM on 06/05/09
User Info.
HometownHero's Avatar
I'll never listen to this haha but she is hot. And a god awful actress
11:16 AM on 06/05/09
Scott Weber
Live Like a Legend
User Info.
Scott Weber's Avatar
this chick ruined one tree hill, i mean i don't watch that show....

seriously though, she ruined it.
11:17 AM on 06/05/09
saved latin. What did you ever do?
User Info.
bladerdude360's Avatar
I think my sister got her first album because it's on my iPod, but I actually enjoy some of the stuff on it. She has a pretty good voice and although she's not breaking any barriers with her sound I think she makes some good songs. Probably won't pick up this album, but maybe a few songs from it.
11:17 AM on 06/05/09
Regular Member
User Info.
~AngelBabi~'s Avatar
The deluxe edition has 5 extra tracks. I love this CD and Kate.
11:47 AM on 06/05/09
User Info.
combatchuckaa's Avatar
9 tracks? That's a long EP, not an album.
03:26 PM on 06/05/09
Registered User
User Info.
lifeintherye's Avatar
She's hot, I tried to give her a chance musically though and idk nothing about it hit me.

I'm a sucker for chicks singing I guess, but she hasn't done anything for me, maybe I'll give it another chance but I don't think this cd is a winner.
09:10 PM on 06/05/09
I want love for us all
User Info.
boxingwithstars's Avatar
to be honest, i preferred her debut album a lot more. i'm not sold on this one yet, none of the tracks are as catchy as "No Good" was off her first album for me.

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate