Album Review
Modest Mouse - Sad Sappy Sucker Album Cover

Modest Mouse - Sad Sappy Sucker

Reviewed by
Modest Mouse - Sad Sappy Sucker
Label: K Records
Release: April 24, 2001
"Self pity, me so pitiful. You can see that birds and worms don't get along"

So begins a blast from the past from Brock and company. Sad Sappy Sucker was originally intended to be Modest Mouse's debut record but remained unreleased until shortly after The Moon & Antarctica arrived. In a nutshell, this collection of unreleased/Dial-A-Song tracks will appeal mainly to big fans of the band. Listening to the music sixteen years later and with a much more impressive resume to the band's name, makes Sad Sappy Sucker more than just lackluster. Indeed, to be blunt, it isn't very good.

The tracks don't come without merit, however. For instance, "Worms Vs. Birds" is a good tune and one can imagine how better it would have sounded in 1994 when most of the tracks were recorded. Brock's voice is young but musically you can see the first signs of This Is a Long Drive for Someone With Nothing to Think About or even Lonesome Crowded West.

The next good tune isn't until track ten with "Every Penny Fed Cat". The song originally appeared on the "Birds vs. Worms" 7" that appeared in 1997 on a limited pressing of 500 copies on blue vinyl. Jeremiah Green's pounding drums make the song standout, even if Brock's vocals and lyrics aren't as fully developed.

"Mice Eat Cheese" is an enjoyable track with a slow brooding drumline and dreamy guitar work. Brock sings, "What are you doing here? I came to get a case of factory outlet beer, then I go home. I don't feel like I want to be by myself." Clearly, Brock was able at the age of nineteen to write great lines and practice has made (near) perfect.

After the initial twelve songs, comes a series of Dial-A-Song tracks. A good portion of them were released on the vinyl only EP Blue Cadet 3, Do You Connect? Yes, it's like They Might Be Giants. They're funny but not much more than that.

Overall, Sad Sappy Sucker has some good tunes that even casual Modest Mouse fans would like. I cleverly pointed them out to you so that you don't purchase the whole album. This is a release by fans, for fans.

Recommended If You LikeModest Mouse

This review is a user submitted review from nineinchsin. You can see all of nineinchsin's submitted reviews here.
Displaying posts 1 - 6 of 6
02:23 AM on 08/13/10
Allez l'OL
User Info.
JuneJuly's Avatar
04:44 AM on 08/13/10
Not Ever Or Anyone
User Info.
flash_gorton's Avatar
Read the first paragraph.
06:32 AM on 08/13/10
We shouldnt have abandoned dreaming
User Info.
jtyexists9's Avatar
The Moon & Antarctica was such a damn good release. I think that album and the Lonesome Crowded West were a ton better than Good News was but I still dug that album.
08:07 AM on 08/13/10
Midtown Saves.
User Info.
RiCCioLi's Avatar
this album is fun for me, but im also a huge modest mouse fan. i have this on vinyl
12:29 PM on 08/13/10
Registered User
User Info.
hello299's Avatar
And the Modest Mouse review saga continues!

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate