Almost every song on their last record sounded the same to me. I thought it was really boring and didn't care for it all (only liked "Detroit"), but it seems like a few that shared that opinion say this is a step up. I'll have to give it a spin soon. There's a lot of hype surrounding it here.
I don't care about the score but good review. You nailed it. I disliked Teeth at first, but it's probably the song that made me think of them from an above average pop punk band to one that deserves a lot of positive attention. Was not a fan of the debut, but this is great.
And big question mark indeed. Song reminded me of TWY's Hey Thanks, but didn't click as much for me.