Album Review
The Story So Far - Under Soil And Dirt Album Cover

The Story So Far - Under Soil And Dirt

Reviewed by
The Story So Far - Under Soil And Dirt
Release Date: June 21, 2011
Record Label: Pure Noise Records
This review was written by an AP.net staff member.
I don’t know much about boxing, but that’s okay because I mostly write about music. I do know that some boxers try to spar, take a lot of damage while only dishing out well-placed blows. Other boxers are more aggressive, the heavy hitters who take a lot of swings and try to land punishing punches. Of course, when you take a lot of big swings, there are risks involved – missing a punch can hurt and you might end up paying the price.

The Story So Far is definitely a pop-punk heavyweight. The good news for the California-bred outfit and their outstanding debut full-length, Under Soil And Dirt, is that most of the big blows are landed. With aggressive musicianship and passionate, on-the-line vocals that bring back memories of Set Your Goals’ Reset EP and Mutiny! full length, The Story So Far writes the exact type of pop-punk you want to hear out of a band in its early stages.

Under Soil And Dirt sounds like it was written in a garage by a bunch of kids in their early 20s, but also sounds like it was recorded with a bunch of nice-looking microphones. Parker Cannon’s lead vocals certainly benefit from the improved production value, while the musicianship is a major notch up from previous releases. The introductory track of “States and Minds” into “Roam” is a solid balance between musicianship that is more thought out than expected and a major hook in the chorus. The hook lands again in “Quicksand,” as slightly troubled youths in the suburbs will easily sing along to the chorus of, “This quicksand / It pulls me under.”

“High Regards” and “Mt. Diablo” make the middle of this album its most important part, as both of the songs are similarly structured and equally catchy. These songs, most specifically the brilliant “Mt. Diablo,” are the knockout blows that make Under Soil And Dirt something that I’ll come back to time and time again. The end of the 11-song effort sees a solid closer in “Closure” (nice), but it’s almost overshadowed by the forever-sing-along-able chorus of the acoustic-based “Placeholder.”

Under Soil And Dirt is part of the new school of pop-punk with all of those hardcore influences, but it’s not like the endless list of records that mess up that formula. It’s music that you’ve heard before, but delivered with such an urgent force that it makes you pay attention. There are no corny breakdowns – instead there are actual well thought-out portions of musicianship. There isn’t an unnecessary overflow of gang vocals and there are no awkwardly placed screams.

The Story So Far is already doing this sort of pop-punk better than the bands that started it – Under Soil And Dirt has enough firepower to rival Mutiny! and it’s certainly better than Set Your Goals’ upcoming release. Somewhere in the middle between the slightly cornier side of the genre and the passionate, desperate core that provides for these angry, angsty songs, The Story So Far shows the potential to develop into a frontrunner in the genre, and it all starts with Under Soil And Dirt.

Recommended If You LikeThe fun-ness of bands like Set Your Goals mixed with the urgency and desperateness of early-decade pop-punk like Tell All Your Friends or New Found Glory's self-titled album.
Bare Essentials1. States and Minds
2. Roam
3. Quicksand
4. Swords and Pens
5. High Regard
6. Daughters
7. Mt. Diablo
8. Four Years
9. Rally Cap
10. Placeholder
11. Closure
Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 89
12:08 AM on 06/23/11
Regular Member
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
I really love this record.
Still Black Veil Brides > Everything.
12:31 AM on 06/23/11
Steve Holt is a bastard.
User Info.
shawnPLAGUES's Avatar
This record is pretty damn good. Might go see these guys with I Call Fives in about two weeks.
12:47 AM on 06/23/11
man I'm pretty
User Info.
M.Lee's Avatar
What an amazing first comment.
12:48 AM on 06/23/11
User Info.
Demilition's Avatar
This album kicked ultimate ass.
12:56 AM on 06/23/11
User Info.
Avalanche1's Avatar
This record is amazing. Highly recommend everyone check it out.
01:21 AM on 06/23/11
Lindsay let me kiss your forehead!
User Info.
suicidalmoose's Avatar
the comparison with boxing was interesting but it fit in well. nice record, I was surprised.
01:30 AM on 06/23/11
Support local music!
User Info.
Jaimehere's Avatar
And I thought the new Fireworks and The Wonder Years records would be my favorite Pop Punk release this year

then TSSF released this and it's now my favorite.

I love the honesty and passion of the vocals, he sounds like he wants to fucking cry but can't so he just sings his heart out.
01:37 AM on 06/23/11
Music makes life bearable!
User Info.
Gautz's Avatar
Loved their ep so will definitely check this out!

Also first comment speaks so much truth.
01:45 AM on 06/23/11
Goodbye Cool World.
User Info.
yayitsjoe's Avatar
this record is really too good. my top three pop-punk records this year, thus far:

1. 61 Penn - Crucial Dudes.
2. Under Soil and Dirt - The Story So Far OR Gospel - Fireworks.
3. Suburbia, I've Given You All and Now I'm Nothing - The Wonder Years.
02:04 AM on 06/23/11
Support local music!
User Info.
Jaimehere's Avatar
this record is really too good. my top three pop-punk records this year, thus far:

1. 61 Penn - Crucial Dudes.
2. Under Soil and Dirt - The Story So Far OR Gospel - Fireworks.
3. Suburbia, I've Given You All and Now I'm Nothing - The Wonder Years.


I forgot to give some love to Crucial Dudes, the album is also fucking awesome.
03:47 AM on 06/23/11
Ryan Gardner
User Info.
Ryan Gardner's Avatar
Really dig this record. Good review.

Not too big of a fan of SYG's latest, though
03:52 AM on 06/23/11
Regular Member
User Info.
TheSlug's Avatar
Rating's too low.
04:04 AM on 06/23/11
User Info.
jusscali's Avatar
This record is fucking awesome - huge surprise
04:59 AM on 06/23/11
Playfully witty sign-off
User Info.
PetitnaindesÎles's Avatar
Vocals should be higher imo

Great record and one of my favorite of the year at this point

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate