[spiffa0]

Originally Posted by M.Lee

If you're talking about starting QBs with a ring, Eli is still last. Hope that helps you out.

haha

[greenteaallday]

Originally Posted by ellie117

Thank you, I'm glad someone else laughed along with me.

Just like I was laughing when he put up 4 tds on the eagles this season.

[MyBestFiend]

1. Tom Brady
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Drew Brees
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Philip Rivers
6. Tony Romo
7. Matt Ryan
8. Matthew Stafford
9. Matt Schaub
10. Michael Vick
11. Josh Freeman
12. Eli Manning
13. Joe Flacco
14. Ryan Fitzpatrick
15. Jay Cutler
16. Matt Hasselbeck
17. Sam Bradford
18. Cam Newton
19. Jason Campbell
20. Mark Sanchez
21. Colt McCoy
22. Matt Cassel
23. Alex Smith
24. Kevin Kolb
25. Andy Dalton
26. Donovan McNabb
27. Rex Grossman
28. Tarvaris Jackson
29. Blaine Gabbert
30. Tim Tebow
31. Curtis Painter
32. Matt Moore

If Orton is still the starter I'd put him between Newton and Campbell.

[kyle is hk]

Originally Posted by M.Lee

If you're talking about starting QBs with a ring, Eli is still last. Hope that helps you out.

lol the only other starting QBs with rings right now are Brady, Rodgers, Big Ben, and Drew Brees. Its not much of an insult to be last on that list

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

eh, disagree. stafford showed promise before this year, but i'm not ready to say he's better than ryan based off five games. eli throws way too many picks/makes way too many dumb mistakes. cassel is... cassel. there's a reason every chiefs fan on this site (both of them?) despise cassel and are dying to win the suck for luck campaign.

Eli makes mistakes, he also gets a shit ton of tipped interceptions off his own receiver's hands. It's actually incredible. There were 8 last year.

I'd definitely take Stafford over Ryan though. No questions asked.

[Carolina.Alex]

Originally Posted by Tyler Vagyler

1. Cam Newton

He's made a believer out of me.

[M.Lee]

Originally Posted by kyle is hk

lol the only other starting QBs with rings right now are Brady, Rodgers, Big Ben, and Drew Brees. Its not much of an insult to be last on that list

You forgot about Peyton, who's still #1 on the depth chart even though he's not technically starting I guess but yeah I was just fucking with him.

[MyBestFiend]

Cassel over Ryan... hahaha wow.

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

Eli makes mistakes, he also gets a shit ton of tipped interceptions off his own receiver's hands. It's actually incredible. There were 8 last year.

I'd definitely take Stafford over Ryan though. No questions asked.

stafford's one of my favorite players in the league, but he also benefits more from calvin johnson than any other qb does from their no. 1 receiver.

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

Eli makes mistakes, he also gets a shit ton of tipped interceptions off his own receiver's hands. It's actually incredible. There were 8 last year.

just watched the first three, all high throws, no shit they're gonna clang off the wr's finger tips.

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

stafford's one of my favorite players in the league, but he also benefits more from calvin johnson than any other qb does from their no. 1 receiver.

Make that argument about Schaub and his johnson too ..pause..

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

just watched the first three, all high throws, no shit they're gonna clang off the wr's finger tips.

not one of those were CLOSE to being uncatchable. They're professional recievers...if you can't catch those with gloves on...jesus.

[startBBtoday]

no. 4 thrown into triple coverage, no. 5 was wide, no. 6 thrown into double coverage as he's being hit, no. 7 was a bad throw, no. 8 was underthrown, no. 9 was high... this is not going well.

[KidRobot]

Originally Posted by startBBtoday

no. 4 thrown into triple coverage, no. 5 was wide, no. 6 thrown into double coverage as he's being hit, no. 7 was a bad throw, no. 8 was underthrown, no. 9 was high... this is not going well.

They're interceptions...they're not going to go well.

he's not Brady ( no matter how much he tells himself that) but I'd be hard pressed to find 20 qb's over the past 5 years I'd rather have.

[startBBtoday]

Originally Posted by KidRobot

Make that argument about Schaub and his johnson too ..pause..



not one of those were CLOSE to being uncatchable. They're professional recievers...if you can't catch those with gloves on...jesus.

when wrs are jumping as high as they can and they're only glancing off their finger tips? those might not be "uncatchable" but it's also eli's fault for throwing too high.

[xbrokendownx]

Eli is good but hes not great

he reminds me a lot of Jay Fiedler when he was with Miami, but better obviously