Album Review
The Gaslight Anthem - Sink Or Swim Album Cover

The Gaslight Anthem - Sink Or Swim

Reviewed by
The Gaslight Anthem- Sink Or Swim
Release Date: May 29th, 2007
Record Label: XOXO Records

New Jersey must be a breeding ground for good music. Spawning some of the largest names in the scene over the past few years, the state seems to be harboring the next big thing every few months. From the passion of Thursday to the emotion of Saves The Day, no genre is left untouched. It appears that the Garden State has spat up just what is needed in the recent sea of watered down releases; an honest to God, no frills punk rock record. Fans of Against Me! rejoice, New Jersey punks The Gaslight Anthem might have just released your new favorite record.

Although only forming in 2005, The Gaslight Anthem sound like a band that has been playing together for a decade. In fact, the comfort and maturity of their full length debut is so evident on just one spin of the disc that by the second run through, you will even feel as if you have been listening to them for a decade due to the instant familiarity demanded from Sink or Swim. While typically a stickler for originality, the lack of new ground broken on the release doesn’t seem to bother me. Perhaps it’s the catchiness or maybe even the sheer sincerity with which the words are crafted, but either way, a majority of the songs are strong enough that little qualms can be overlooked when listening to the final product. Though laced with a mix of folk sing-alongs, soul and even an acoustic ballad, Sink or Swim never strays too far from its core punk rock sound. The Gaslight Anthem realized what they do best and, admirably, didn’t try to expand out of their comfort zone. This, based on opinion, could be the album’s greatest strength or its largest weakness, but after spending a lot of time with the record, it didn’t bother me one bit. From the power chords to the soaring, melodic gang vocals, songs such as “Wooderson” and “We’re Getting A Divorce, You Keep The Diner” are chock full of everything you would expect to hear in a great punk song. On the softer side of things, there are two entirely acoustic songs on Sink or Swim. “The Navesink Banks” and “Red At Night” may be not be plugged in, but their melancholic atmosphere is a perfect interlude to the energetic punk that surrounds them.

Vocalist Brian Fallon has a talent for creating lyrics and melodies that are simple and catchy, yet never forced or unintelligent. “I Coulda Been A Contender” is the highlight of the album, both musically and vocally. The verses, which sound purposely restrained and believable, give way to a huge chorus sure to be sung at live shows for years to come. It is just a good rock song that shows off the many facets of Fallon’s voice while displaying the technical know how of the musicians. Fallon’s voice falls somewhere along the spectrum between Bad Religion’s Greg Graffin and Jawbreaker’s Blake Schwarzenbach in his prime. It wouldn’t be out of line to assume that The Gaslight Anthem is paying homage to both bands with certain vocal subtleties that could be considered nods to the definitive punk bands. While we are on the subject of similar sounding bands, it would be difficult to not mention influence of future tour mates Against Me!. The “woahs” on “Boomboxes and Dictionaries” seems as if it was directly ripped from Against Me!’s “Sink. Florida. Sink.”, but I guess imitation is the highest form of flattery, because it works in both songs. Even though there are traces of the band’s influence all over Sink or Swim, it is utilized in a way that doesn’t detract from the credibility of The Gaslight Anthem. Despite the comparisons, there is enough here for the band to stand on its own. They have created a great punk rock record and an incredibly solid debut. If The Gaslight Anthem continue on this path, I see big things for future releases and a growing fan base. While it may not be the most original, at the very least Sink or Swim will tide over fans awaiting a new Against Me! disc.

Tracklisting1. Boomboxes and Dictionaries
2. I Coul'da Been A Contender
3. Wooderson
4. We Came To Dance
5. 1930
6. The Navesink Banks
7. Red In The Morning
8. I'da Called You Woody, Joe
9. Angry Johnny And The Radio
10. Drive
11. We're Getting A Divorce, You Keep The Diner
12. Red At Night
Listen to The Gaslight AnthemMyspace | Purevolume | XOXO Records Site
This review is a user submitted review from Tom Good. You can see all of Tom Good's submitted reviews here.
Displaying posts 1 - 15 of 26
09:13 AM on 06/25/07
bippity boppity
User Info.
Praetor's Avatar
Great review, this band should be doing much better than they are.
09:52 AM on 06/25/07
Just a dab'll do ya
User Info.
Mase714's Avatar
great review, just picked this cd up the other week and it's been on rotation non-stop. I'd love to see these guys live, there songs are perfect for sing-a-long's.
09:59 AM on 06/25/07
User Info.
j.maziarski's Avatar
I would compare them to Face to Face alot...anyone else?
10:57 AM on 06/25/07
bounce bitch bounce
User Info.
dretti's Avatar
You've sparked my interest in this band, and I really like the songs on their myspace. I'm definitely going to have to check this out. Great Review.
11:06 AM on 06/25/07
Registered Gangsta
User Info.
turbonium's Avatar
I dont even like punk but these guys are really good writers.
11:45 AM on 06/25/07
User Info.
llmp's Avatar
My favorite release of 07 so far...and probably is going to stay that way. Haven't been able to listen to any of my other new records because I just keep listening to this.

Are they the most original band? No, but damn they're good at what they do. This years No Trigger to me..
02:18 PM on 06/25/07
such a registered user
User Info.
jasoneyeball's Avatar
awesome band. i hope they explode
02:29 PM on 06/25/07
yeeeeeeeeeaaaaah boooooy
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
amazing album. amazing live show. poorly written review.
03:39 PM on 06/25/07
Tom Good
Album Reviewer
User Info.
Tom Good's Avatar
I would compare them to Face to Face alot...anyone else?
I can see where you are coming from with that.
05:48 PM on 06/25/07
Go AWAY! Batin'!
User Info.
Justin_stacy's Avatar
this will probably go down as the best album of the year. with 1930 being my favorite song.
06:58 PM on 06/25/07
Tom Good
Album Reviewer
User Info.
Tom Good's Avatar
this will probably go down as the best album of the year. with 1930 being my favorite song.
that's a great song. It's pretty catchy
07:15 PM on 06/25/07
Registered User
User Info.
No Avatar Selected
i've had the pleasure of these handome boys playing in my basement in new brunswick and it was so punk rock, i had to shit my pants in order to equate my level of punk rawkness to the situation around me. they have yet to give me a complimentary copy of the record. what the hell guys? :)
08:56 PM on 06/25/07
User Info.
Daveyhavok832's Avatar
just got it today... sounds pretty solid.
09:03 PM on 06/25/07
Bow down to Xenu
User Info.
PunkENG's Avatar
I can't decide if this album or The Swellers is #1 of '07. Really amazing album.

Search News
Release Dates
Best New Music
Submit News
Mobile Version
AP.net Logos
Encore Podcast
Free Music
Sports Forum
Technology Forum
Contact Us
Copyright Policy
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy
Twitter | Facebook | RSS
Encore Podcast on iTunes
Encore on Overcast
AP.net on Tumblr
Chorus.fm | @jason_tate