I will always hold the belief that (putting aside band members' attitudes/live show etc.) their debut was not bad. At the very worst I think they're average or generic. If you listen to the cd on a decent system it's alright. They have a few good parts here and there and some of the lyrics are surprisingly good. They're not fucking sweet or anything and I don't want to defend their honor so to speak but I think people over exaggerated their suckiness, lol.
I'd still say they're embarassingly bad. Would rather have a joke rap CD than some other generic metalcore band, so I'm gonna reverse the thoughts of my initial GIF and say this could be dece. If he's actually funny. If he's trying to be taken seriously it should be garbage.