[trevorshmevor]

BOATS is arguably my favorite album of all time.... so that one. Some favorites from it: Surprise Surprise, Artistic License, Ready. I love their other two albums and acoustic EP as well, though.

Sadly, I was a little let down by the live versions of "Luck". Maybe a studio version would be better, but it really just sounded bland to me. I guess I don't have much to say in terms of what direction I hope they'll go in the future, but I do hope that if/when they do return, it will be because it's something that they've found an irresistible crave for.

[saintnumberfive]

BOATS is so so good. Cut! Print It is a perfect closing song for that album. And the B-List is great too.

I will say Island may be my fav TSL song overall though..

[GetUpAndrew]

The Starting Line are one of my all time favorite bands, so that's a hard choice, for me, but if I had to pick an album from them, I'd go with Say It Like You Mean It.

[BusterBluth]

Direction, I kinda hate Say It Like You Mean It

[Alex DiVincenzo]

They're all good, but SILYMI is by far my favorite.

[bituin01]

I'd say Direction is my favourite. Definitely going to try to grab a copy of the vinyl.

[friskycurtain]

Based On A True Story...however, my favorite songs by TSL are What You Want, Leaving, and Three's A Charm.

[StepsInADance]

Originally Posted by LifeOfDefiance

Notsureifsrs.

Most definitely serious.

[Mario57]

Direction, which is one of my favorite albums of all time. Unfortunately i couldn't get into the two others full lenghts :/

[blinkme]

Based On a True Story. 'Something Left to Give' is probably my favourite song they've ever released, though.

[JamesMichael]

Say it like you mean it is definitely at the top for me due to it being one of the first Pop-Punk albums I properly got into and the nostalgia it now has for me. Also it has one of my favourite songs ever on it 'Cheek to Cheek'

[therailwayhouse]

this is pretty difficult for me, but probably Based On A True Story

[Troggy]

I guess Say It Like You Mean it, but TSL is a pretty mediocre band. Curious somewhat related question, is there any interest out there for autographed copies of SILYMI? Probably not much of a rarity, I suppose.

[Truman122]

BOATS, if only because and Artistic License and Autography.

[daftpunker45]

Direction is fantastic. BOATS has grown on me, and Say It Like You Mean It is great, it's the only one I need on CD to complete my TSL CD collection.