You can head to the replies to watch four high-quality acoustic videos from Bayside's show at Fred Perry's Surplus Store in Brooklyn, N.Y. Among them is a great version of "Talking of Michelangelo," which is rarely played by the band.
I've heard them play Talking of Michelangelo several times live. I think Anthony likes playing that song. That and Phone Call from Poland are some of the more common deeper cuts they still play. Great song, that guitar at the beginning has such a dark tone.