Samsung Galaxy SIII, HTC One X, or the LG Nitro. The Motorola Atrix HD also looks good, and is coming out on Sunday.
I've been looking at the SIII and I'm thinking that's going to be the one I'll upgrade to. The ability to upgrade up to 64GB via microSD and the $150 price at Best Buy/Wal-Mart basically wooed me. The Atrix looks pretty good too, I'll have to look into the price for it though.
Yeah, I don't see how you could really make that comparison. As it's been put already, you're comparing the sale of a sea of Android phones to a handful of Apple phones. No wonder one side has more sales.