Well apparently I lucked out because TBS were really sharp and all around pretty great. It was pretty awesome seeing Nolan up there playing with them having a great time. They started out with basically the songs/singles you'd expect from their other albums, then went through TAYF and finished off with The Ballad of Sal Villanueva and Your Own Disaster. The only bad thing I have to say about the show is that some crowd-surfing chick fell on my head and knocked my glasses off. I found them with some help from a couple good samaritans but they were broken. Oh well.
I think that show comes to Cleveland on the 24th. Very much considering going. I've never really listened to Touche Amore or Balance and Composure but both Circa and O'Brother are amazing live.