I'm super glad I wasn't shit on for that haha. I've only listened to TBC, SWYA, and Daybreak. I have STA though.
It's funny. TBC was the first album I heard by this band. I thought it was good, but it didn't hold my attention. The next album I heard by Saves The Day was Daybreak. Makes you wonder what the hell happened in between.
Musically, I would change nothing on Daybreak. Everything is executed so well. Spencer did a great job on drums. As drummer, I sometimes think to myself "oh this drummer should have done something like this here," but I did not think any of that on Daybreak. I would change nothing.