If they were one of your favorites why would you stop listening to them?
I remember there was like a four year gap between SYOF and the record after that. I think I listened to a few tracks off that record but couldn't get into it.
I'll have to listen tonight. They did a cool thing where you got a free download of the new album (when it comes out) if you bought tickets to their latest tour.
I really liked the 5 Ghosts... so either that means from your comments that this is REALLY good or we have very different tastes as Stars fans. Hopefully it's the former.