You've still got 3 days left to run, I guarantee you it will go up. I was pretty surprised to see them going for as much as they do.
Well, her's seems pretty much spot on for what they've been going at. I've counted 9 listings from the same record shop in indiana supposedly selling the record for 70-200. it's suspicious to me because there's only 1 buyout bid on each of their listings. There are a few signed listings I've seen go for pretty high but otherwise I've been seeing them go for 40-70. The problem I really see here is just there is the same record shop reselling their record inflating the price. Also note, just this past month a 1st pressing was sold for $100.
See for yourself
I don't want to feel like I'm ripping you off so I didn't bother telling you that when you hoped to sell it for much more than the $50 I was offering. Maybe I'm just being misguided here though. With my wedding only 2 weeks away I can't really make an offer that you feel is reasonable either way so I do wish both of you the best of luck.