It's not a standard way of re-interpreting this beautiful song but I really like it..I think the maine and adam did a great job like relient k...really different versions of the same song but they're both great

I think we all want a return to form from the Punk Goes… series, but as long as the scenies keep buying them, they're still going to be awful. That being said, I can't listen to this (thanks, Hurricane Sandy) but seeing Adam is on this surprising. That Call Me Maybe cover was atrocious, and the Gotye cover was boring and uninspired.

Still think Starfucker has the best cover of this song.

Originally Posted by Collin182

Still think Starfucker has the best cover of this song.

I had never heard of this group but this cover is good. The vocals are good and the bass is funky. I still think the cover The Maine is the best re-imaging of the song but this is a really good cover.

damn, i actually like this

Originally Posted by Searos

I had never heard of this group but this cover is good. The vocals are good and the bass is funky. I still think the cover The Maine is the best re-imaging of the song but this is a really good cover.

You should check out their self titled album if you get the chance, it's a good listen.

Good cover. This along with Mayday's cover were the best on PGP this time around.

I don't think this quite beats out Relient K for the best version of this song, but I do love the new structure and Adam's feature in it.

Originally Posted by Searos

I love The Maine's new sound way more than their old sound and they totally re-imagine this sound which is what I love.

Definitely agree. They have great production on this song, as well as the last album. Super clean and sounds great.

Originally Posted by Mikenovacane

Definitely agree. They have great production on this song, as well as the last album. Super clean and sounds great.

I am glad they don't want to be a neon-pop band anymore. The Maine actually grew up and got better at music.

Only good song on the record. Mayday's cover would have been ok if not for the autotune on Derek's voice.

Absolutely loving this cover.

this isn't punk, this is hardcore/ screamo....

Originally Posted by 1000shadesofred

this isn't punk, this is hardcore/ screamo....

nothing about this song is hardcore or screamo.

Originally Posted by Helen Keller.

Honestly, I feel the exact opposite way with the exception of the Mayday cover. The Word Alive's Mercy cover is unreal.

Unreal? I don't know about that. I'm a fanboy of Life Cycles and I didn't enjoy it that much. Not bad, but the best parts of the song are the "It is a weeping and a moaning and a gnashing of teeth". Love what they did with part.

I somehow missed the release of Punk Goes Pop 4. When was that put out?