I've tried to like Gaslight forever, and I just can't seem to. But it would make much more sense for them to be in the top five. "Vital" is Anberlin's like, fourth best record.
Yeah with Gaslighht all the references throughout the '59 Sound made it a classic to me. I can listen over and over trying to pick out different parts. As a huge Tom Waits fan, I still get a kick out of Fallon quoting "Ol' 55", "Bring a dollar with you baby, in the cold, cold ground" or "Monroe hips". I listened to it over and over until I really loved the actual sound they bring.
I always thought Anberlin was overrated (don't sue me) and Vital is the worst record of theirs I have invested any time in.