Almost nobody did. I think they only went on one full band tour between the release of Paper Walls and the hiatus. On that tour (at least on the live album) they played The Takedown, Fighting, Keeper, Light Up the Sky and Shadows and Regrets. And since they've come back, I've also seen them play Shrink the World, Five Becomes Four and Cut Me Mick, plus I saw a video of them playing Dear Bobbie acoustic in Japan I think.
That's most of the album, which is pretty impressive considering how many albums they have to pull from.
I also saw them play Gifts and Curses live which was really surprising/outstanding!
Jealous! I walways play the song "Paper Walls" on the drive home from a concert. I know they'll never play it since they have so many other songs that more people want to see, but it's still my favorite song of theirs.