I think Jimmy Eat World is definitely a little bit lower, however. A few years back I think they could be that high, but now I don't really agree.
During the release of Bleed American and Futures, I'd say it would have been hard to find a bigger alternative rock band. For that alone they deserve to be in the top 5. They just have been at it so long I feel like they don't get looked at as a "big" band anymore.