Understatement in the Brand New part. The Shone thread was THE biggest thread in the website's history. Jason can correct me if that's wrong but I'm pretty sure.

Originally Posted by Keagan Ilvonen

What Dustin said, I tried to keep all discussion in that one thread which led it to be the biggest of all time, BUT it just beat out Blink and the Blink discussion flooded into the Grammy thread and others.

It has double the comments as the thread in second place and 200,000 more views than the thread in second place in that category. It didn't "just" beat out anything haha.