that last album was a semi-standard above average anthem alt rock/indie pop album. I dunno who overrates them, but chances are, they aren't the best to go to when it comes to music.
try their first album. it's a fuckton better than some nights.
I remember first listening to Aim & Ignite when the YouTube streams went up. Can't believe how good "Be Calm" still sounds to me. IMO, it's their best song to date (except The Gambler)