This is their best work, but still easy to file under boring / uninspiring / generic / etc. I'd lump them in with Polar Bear Club, The Wonder Years, etc, in that they are bands that are by no means bad, but also not an essential listen.
There are handfuls of bands doing this style much better.
(Obligatory "this is my opinion" comment, because idiots have a tendency to get butthurt when others express their own negative thoughts on something they personally have a positive opinion on.)
I don't find this album to be all that generic, as I touched on. Think it has a whole lot more uniqueness to it than Wonder Years.