I'll probably get roasted for this but...
I think Brand New is popular on this site for nostalgia reasons riding the wave from their highly well received sophomore album even though their last two albums were met with mixed reviews. And the hype is for them to make an album that is just as great and they're just as bad as Saosin in regards to being mysterious. Just my opinion.
I'd say that TDAG is seen by most fans as their best album -- and is definitely the higher rated of the two when it comes to reviews
(Daisy is higher than Deja from a critical review stand point).
And I've never seen 1/100th of this buzz (here or elsewhere) for Saosin.