The membar ratings, HAH. WHAT A JOKE. This album and this band is perfection.

Originally Posted by nowFace

100%?! shit might have to listen to this. Last time AP gave an album that to my knowledge was Bon Iver, and I loved that album.

I think it was The Gaslight Anthem - Handwritten that last got 100% here, actually.

All I heard in my head while reading the review was Quagmire saying : "This is ridiculous !"

Nice review, 100% is a little exaggerated but it's a great album nonetheless.

Originally Posted by Charlesieiy

I think it was The Gaslight Anthem - Handwritten that last got 100% here, actually.

Really? That completely devalues the rating.

You write extremely well. This was a good review! I'm impressed you're only 17-18. I wrote terribly at that age lol.

Originally Posted by StepsInADance

Really? That completely devalues the rating.

I mean, 2 completely different reviewers.

Originally Posted by vivatoto56

I mean, 2 completely different reviewers.

I mean, I'm not really being totally serious.

Originally Posted by StepsInADance

I mean, I'm not really being totally serious.

Oh, then carry on.

GREAT album, and great review! Completely agree with it.

Originally Posted by StepsInADance

Really? That completely devalues the rating.

Haha! 100% is always an exaggeration, anyway.

Originally Posted by Kelly Doherty

Nah, Isn't Anything came out in 1988, The Stone Roses came out 1989. Loveless came out 1991, Second Coming came out in 1994.

Yo just quoting you to say I went back and listened to Sugar and it all makes sense now haha. Keep on keepin on

should be "recommended if you like: good fucking music"

but yeah, great job kelly :D

dayum 10/10

I will admit my ignorance and say that I don't think I had ever heard of this band until the lead singer said that a new album was coming out a few days before it did, and everybody freaked out.
Since people seemed to hyped about it, I decided to check it out once it was actually released.

And after listening to it (and not liking it), and now seeing the ratings for this review, I just have one thing to say, are you serious?
I mean this obviously isn't my kind of music (and if other people do more power to them I guess) but a perfect 10? C'mon man!

One of the tracks is LITERALLY the same 3 seconds repeated over and over again for 3 and a half minutes

Like seriously, what the fuck is that?
How can an album that features a track and uncreative and lame as that get all 10s?

(I do realize that is probably the worst track on the album, btw. And even though I totally disagree with it, the review was well written.)