Bring Me the Horizon? Is that album really special (not being smart ass, general inquiry)

Originally Posted by Jason Tate

I don't think so. But that's just me.

I didn't think so, the few songs I heard from them sounded like everything else from the genre

Originally Posted by RockVocalPower

So? It was one of the biggest mainstream breakouts this scene has EVER seen. It will be a classic.

I think it depends on how we define "classic". In 1997 the band Days of the New was #1 on Billboard Mainstream Rock for 16 straight weeks.. Not sure we consider them a classic though..

I feel fun. will be similar.. Those that are in the scene that knew of them prior to their exposure will continue on and think of them as classic, whereas true mainstream (with their short attention) will move onto the next fad..

Just my opinion though

Was never my thing, but people often talk about A Day To Remember - Homesick being a great album

Originally Posted by SpyKi

do they?

"Classic" for the Hot Topic crowd perhaps?