I enjoy a lot of these but it's way too soon to talk about all of these albums as classics.

Originally Posted by Zack Zarrillo

It's a tie-in with our new Decade feature for current classics/10 year tours.

Ah okay this makes sense then. As far as this goes then I can really see The Menzingers reaching this status within this "community". On the Impossible Past is a record that sounds new but at the same time it already has that nostalgic feeling to it. Same goes for Listen and Forgive.

Originally Posted by Jake Jenkins

the national will go down as one of the best bands of this generation, as will radiohead.

I think Radiohead has already been there for years.

Originally Posted by Jake Jenkins

well, yeah, that's very true. i don't think they could possibly do anything to turn that around either

They cemented that with OK Computer in my mind.