That album might be their best. The first had too many annoying songs, mostly in the first half. In Vices & Virtues, Let's Kill Tonight all the way to Trade Mistakes are really good pop rock songs (along with the best track, Nearly Witches). The rest I don't care for, but I find the quality of that album above that of their first two.
I should probably explain what I meant. In quite a few songs on the album, they had like 30 second or longer instrumental endings that seem to go on forever, and the entire album is less than 40 minutes long. None of the tracks were complete throw always for me.