Didn't think of this one when I made the thread but I LOVE this album. I think that if Band In a Bubble had not existed that album would have been widely well-received.
Never understood why people didn't like Folie. It really doesn't sound that far off from their other stuff. I mean, each of their albums were gradually more R&B/soul influenced. That album still sounds pretty pop/punky as a whole. The new song is way more of a jump in style than Folie was.
One that I don't think was mentioned in here yet is Lights and Sounds by Yellowcard. I know I personally didn't really like it when it came out but I started liking it a lot more as the years went on.