the Taking Back Sunday/Saves The Day match-up is a toughy for me

I think Matchbook Romance and Finch are missing.

Some of these analyses are completely wrong.

Dads should win it all, but whatever

Hardest choice was TEN vs. HH. The other ones I didn't have much trouble choosing.

Still pulling for JEW, although Brand New would definitely be ok.

Originally Posted by guitarguy211

Hardest choice was TEN vs. HH. The other ones I didn't have much trouble choosing.

same one was tougher for me.

Originally Posted by herbienay

Some of these analyses are completely wrong.

I agree with this.

Also saying Brand New built itself on mysterious bullshit is a bit bold. Wanting to still be able to live normal lives and not be out there in the spotlight, having fans know their personal stories, is not bullshit in my opinion.

Also Saves the Day hasn't been relevant since "Through Being Cool"??? Whaaaaat?

Originally Posted by fenderstrat383

the Taking Back Sunday/Saves The Day match-up is a toughy for me

TBS is the obvious choice.

Originally Posted by pissand409

I agree with this.

Also saying Brand New built itself on mysterious bullshit is a bit bold. Wanting to still be able to live normal lives and not be out there in the spotlight, having fans know their personal stories, is not bullshit in my opinion.

Also Saves the Day hasn't been relevant since "Through Being Cool"??? Whaaaaat?

Stay What You Are was their biggest album, right?
I also disagreed with these
Thursday has no emotional connection to fans in their lyrics? The hell?
Matt Pryor's voice is better than Jeremy Enigk's?

Originally Posted by Meeze

TBS is the obvious choice.

Ha ha ha ha

Originally Posted by Holly HoX!

Ha ha ha ha

Wait...who is Saves the Day?

Yeah, some of the write-ups were borderline infuriating.

I like the TBS analysis...
Strengths:"...tumultuous history..."
Weaknesses: tumultuous history...