I didn't realize they had done so many guest spots. "I'd Do Anything" gets my vote. Even without the Mark factor, it's an awesome track.

Originally Posted by Alex DiVincenzo

I didn't realize they had done so many guest spots. "I'd Do Anything" gets my vote. Even without the Mark factor, it's an awesome track.

Most of the came from their new album.

I don't remember Joel Madden singing on You Don't Mean Anything.

Tough call between I'd Do Anything and Jet Lag with Natasha...but Jet Lag won. That song is awesome!

"I'd Do Anything" has to win my vote. Between Mark Hoppus and the nostalgic factor, it beats them all.

I distinctly remember being "too cool" to listen to these guys, so my perception of how big they were/are in the scene is totally skewed.;

Originally Posted by kidinthebushes

I don't remember Joel Madden singing on You Don't Mean Anything.

I never knew he sang on it til now either. He just sings the low harmony in the chorus. Did some research and found this:

Originally Posted by ghelms88

"I'd Do Anything" has to win my vote. Between Mark Hoppus and the nostalgic factor, it beats them all.

Pretty Much

You Don't Mean Anything is nostalgic as hell for me. Simple Plan and Good Charlotte were both my favorites back then. I haven't heard the song in years!

Regardless, I'd Do Anything gets my vote

I'd Do Anything rules, but I love Alex's part on Freaking Me Out

I do like all of those collabs. Seeing Rivers jam with SP was awesome, I'd Do Anything and You Don't Mean Anything are some of my oldskool faves, but I must say their Jet Lag-single was amazing. So that would get my vote.