For me, Borders is their all-time best followed closely by Hello, Rockview. Borders is one of those albums that was not received well when it was released, but as people get older, they appreciate it more. I have liked things post-Anthem, but they haven't come close to touching Borders yet as far as I am concerned.
Kinda forgot this band is still making new music. I was a big LTJ fan back in the day, I feel like they peaked at Hello Rockview, but I still rock B&B now and then, and even a couple tunes off Anthem. They lost me at "She's Gonna Break Soon" but now I'm interested to see what they're making nowadays.