Did this site have a best of 2004? I remember Tate's best was ... Is A Real Boy, but was there a consensus site opinion? Because PunkNews' was American Idiot and I felt maybe that could have been top of both lists. Also in 2006 The Devil and God was top of PunkNews and could have been for AP.net as well. Any help?
shocked that Punknews chose American Idiot in 04. i personally am a fan of that album but just really surprised that site chose it
Yeah I was too. They chose System of a Down one year (maybe the one before)... these days it's usually a tiny band like Restorations or Joyce Manor when they were starting out.
Also, the year OTIP came number 1 I think Handwritten was 2 on both lists. Cray cray.
Looks likeDog Problems got #1 in 2006. I can't help with '04, but I don't think that people around here like American Idiot enough to vote it #1.
Thanks for posting that, I had no recollection. Boys and Girls in America, Oh Calcutta, the Saosin s/t and A City By The Light Divided were very underrated on that list. +44 way overrated, although Baby Come On was a good song.