I may alone in this but I find their self-title to be their best album. I don't think Jason Lancaster really blossomed into a great song writer till he did worked as the front man of Go Radio. Self-Title felt the most genuine and felt like every member of the band was writing and giving it their all. For me its S/T>ALIR>MITC>ABH.
I think the band has grown a bit stagnant with their last album but it was still filled fun songs at least. I think some songs on ALIR held up great but as a whole the album has that juvenile feel that a lot of debuts have.
Definitely agree, same order as you. S/T is fantastic.