Originally Posted by hockeyguitar99

How can there be a list that supposed to represent our community at least a little bit not include a Brand New album?

It's not supposed to be the be all end all representative list. It's just 15 albums that we think are classic. There are certainly a ton more that would've made the list if we didn't cap it.

Originally Posted by deadkidsean

I would put 6 of these records in my top 12-15 EVER. Just an absolutely perfect list, Julia.

Thank you! The list is a collection of staff's picks, and I think it proves that we actually like music other than SA and BN.

upps to the Propagandhi inclusion

This was a pleasant suprise when ap.net popped up today. Will definitely be checking out the ones i've never taken a look at before

Just curious, who picked Today's Empires, Tomorrow's Ashes? Really glad to see that one on there. Kind of surprising, hah.

Originally Posted by MarkyMark1984

I would have put Further Seems Forever's "The Moon is Down" on the list... but it's one of my favorites of all time.

God I love that album. If the list were just my 15, that wouldve definitely made it on there.

yeah, I'm surprised Deja didn't get on here but it looks like you guys wanted 2000 to be the latest.

I am surprised about Waiting... though. Good album but I wouldnt' call it a classic.

FINALLY someone puts in propagandhi on an all time list. Today's Empires, Tomorrow's Ashes is a great album but I can't wait until people hear Supporting Caste, it will blow your brains out with sheer rockitude.

Solid list. I have (and love) all of those albums except for Deftones.

Would have included Lifetime's Jersey's Best Dancers and Weezer's Pinkerton.

pretty good varied list, i'd throw these into the mix...

jawbreaker - dear you
get up kids = 4 minute mile
alk3 - goddamnit
jets to brazil - orange rhyming dictionary
knapsack - this conversation is ending starting right now
small brown bike - dead reckoning

SEE YOU IN HELL!

Originally Posted by beth danger

Solid list. I have (and love) all of those albums except for Deftones.

Would have included Lifetime's Jersey's Best Dancers and Weezer's Pinkerton.

Jersey's Best Dancers influence hasn't really flourished yet. In only the last 5 or so years the scene is citing them as an influence. Give it 5 more years, and it'll be on lots of lists.

Waiting is sooo great!

Wide Awake > Lifted

Decent enough list though.

Jimmy Eat World's Bleed American tops my list of classics without a doubt

Deeply saddened by the omission of Alkaline Trio's Goddamnit